Controlling Local Charges: The Tax and Fee Boundary After the Collapse of Executive Review

Authors

  • Dina Lusianti Faculty of Economics and Business, Universitas Muria Kudus, Kudus, Indonesia Author

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.69019/jlpf.v2i4.115

Keywords:

local charges, tax and fee distinction, judicial review, subnational regulation, fiscal decentralisation

Abstract

Local governments levy charges as well as taxes, and the line between the two determines which legal guarantees apply to a citizen who must pay. This study examines how that line is drawn and how the proliferation of local charges is controlled, in a system where the principal control mechanism was removed by constitutional ruling and later replaced by a different one. The method combines doctrinal analysis with a structured review of research published between 2017 and 2024 and comparative material from Poland, Serbia, South Africa and the United States. Three findings follow. The control architecture has been rebuilt rather than repaired: a 2017 constitutional ruling invalidated executive review of subnational regulations, holding that review belongs to the courts, and the 2022 fiscal relations statute then substituted ex ante restriction of what may be charged for the ex post annulment that had been removed. The forum that inherited the function reviews subnational law poorly, with decisions found seriously flawed and politically sensitive cases avoided. And the doctrinal question of when a charge is in substance a tax is largely unaddressed in recent scholarship; Polish administrative-court jurisprudence on whether general tax law applies to enumerated local charges is the closest available treatment. The study argues that ex ante closure and ex post review answer different questions, and specifies four criteria a charge should satisfy.

Downloads

Published

2026-11-21

Issue

Section

Doctrinal / Legal Analysis

How to Cite

Controlling Local Charges: The Tax and Fee Boundary After the Collapse of Executive Review. (2026). Journal of Law, Public Policy and Public Finance, 2(4), 37–51. https://doi.org/10.69019/jlpf.v2i4.115

Similar Articles

You may also start an advanced similarity search for this article.