A Ratio That Did Not Move: Fiscal Autonomy Measures and a 37 Trillion Rupiah Loss

Authors

  • Rodyah Widyarini Universitas Primagraha Author

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.69019/jlpf.v2i4.49

Keywords:

fiscal autonomy, ratio measures, own-source revenue, intergovernmental transfers, fiscal indicators

Abstract

Fiscal autonomy is almost universally measured as own-source revenue divided by total revenue. This article shows that the measure has a structural blind spot and documents an instance in which the blind spot obscured a shock of national magnitude. Across all 38 Indonesian provinces, own-source revenue fell from IDR 212.06 trillion in fiscal year 2024 to IDR 174.60 trillion in 2025, a loss of IDR 37.46 trillion or 17.67 per cent, following a statutory reassignment of vehicle taxation. Over the same period intergovernmental transfers fell 10.09 per cent and total revenue 13.77 per cent. Because numerator and denominator moved together, the autonomy ratio fell only from 54.80 to 52.32 per cent in aggregate, and the unweighted mean across provinces from 40.75 to 39.58 — a movement of 1.17 percentage points. Fifteen of the 38 provinces record an increase in their autonomy ratio during the year in which provincial own-source revenue contracted by more than a sixth. The article argues that ratio measures are unreliable indicators of fiscal position whenever the two quantities they compare respond to a common disturbance, that this condition is not exceptional in intergovernmental finance, and that assessment frameworks should report level and composition alongside the ratio. It sets out three diagnostic conditions under which a ratio measure should be distrusted and shows that the present case satisfies all three.

Downloads

Published

2026-11-16

Issue

Section

Policy Analysis

How to Cite

A Ratio That Did Not Move: Fiscal Autonomy Measures and a 37 Trillion Rupiah Loss. (2026). Journal of Law, Public Policy and Public Finance, 2(4), 1–13. https://doi.org/10.69019/jlpf.v2i4.49